Hello everyone! I've been learning Dutch for some time now but reading the section on long and short vowels on this website I came across this sentence "In Dutch, we make a distinction between long and short vowels. This has nothing to do with how long we pronounce a vowel." and I can't really understand what it wants to say. I always thought that there were vowels in Dutch pronounced short and others pronounce longer, like double vowels, that I though were not only more openly pronounced but also long in duration. Below in the same page it also says that "aa" is pronounced [a] and not [a:], while online the resources I checked use the second notation, thus [a:], denoting a long duration. Can anybody help me with this and clear my doubts?
Thank you!
Long vowels and their length
-
- Nieuwkomer
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Sat Dec 21, 2024 10:07 am
- Country of residence: Netherlands
- Mother tongue: Swedish
- Second language: English
- Third language: Mandarin
- Fourth language: Dutch
- Fifth, sixth, seventh, ..., languages: JavaScript, Python
- Location: Amsterdam
- Contact:
Re: Long vowels and their length
Hey!
I think is more about quality/sound than length. If you compare "man" and "maan", sure, one is a long a and one short, but actually saying them you can hear they're more like different sounds, right? They also feel different to pronounce.
Lars
I think is more about quality/sound than length. If you compare "man" and "maan", sure, one is a long a and one short, but actually saying them you can hear they're more like different sounds, right? They also feel different to pronounce.
Lars
- Bieneke
- Site Administrator
- Posts: 2001
- Joined: Wed Aug 10, 2005 11:18 pm
- Country of residence: Netherlands
- Mother tongue: Dutch (Netherlands)
- Second language: English
- Gender: Female
- Location: Maastricht
Re: Long vowels and their length
That is indeed what it is about. The 'long' sounds require more muscle effort but are not necessarily pronounced longer.hetNederlars wrote: ↑Sat Dec 21, 2024 10:14 am Hey!
I think is more about quality/sound than length. If you compare "man" and "maan", sure, one is a long a and one short, but actually saying them you can hear they're more like different sounds, right? They also feel different to pronounce.
Lars
For the 'long a' sound you indeed find both notations: a: and a. E.g.:
/a/ https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klankinve ... Nederlands
/a:/ https://nl.wiktionary.org/wiki/WikiWoor ... Nederlands
Because the duration of the vowel is not longer than for a 'short' vowel, a is a safe choice.
Bieneke
-
- Nieuwkomer
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Mon Dec 16, 2024 7:06 pm
- Country of residence: Italy
- Mother tongue: Italian
- Second language: Macedonian
- Third language: English
- Gender: Male
Re: Long vowels and their length
Thanks a lot to both of you, everything is clear now!!